Nonparametric Likelihood and Doubly Robust Estimating Equations for Marginal and Nested Structural Models
نویسنده
چکیده
Drawing inferences about treatment effects is of interest in many fields. We consider Robins’s marginal and nested structural models and propose likelihood and regression estimators in the cross-sectional setting. First, we choose to retain a finite subset of all inherent and modelling constraints on the the joint distributions of potential outcomes and covariates under a correctly specified propensity score model. We derive a profile likelihood by maximizing the nonparametric likelihood over these joint distributions subject to the retained constraints. The maximum likelihood estimator is asymptotically equivalent to the optimal estimator in the class of estimators that are solutions to linear combinations of estimating equations based on the retained constraints. Second, we derive two regression estimators, named hat and tilde, as first-order approximations to the likelihood estimator under the propensity score model. The tilde regression estimator is intrinsically and weakly locally efficient and doubly robust. By intrinsic efficiency, it is asymptotically guaranteed to gain efficiency over the non-augmented inverse-probability-weighted or G estimator if the propensity score model is correctly specified and over the augmented inverse-probability-weighted or G estimator if the outcome regression model is misspecified but the propensity score model is correctly specified. We illustrate the methods by data analysis for an observational study on right heart catheterization.
منابع مشابه
Marginal and Nested Structural Models Using Instrumental Variables
The objective of many scientific studies is to evaluate the effect of a treatment on an outcome of interest ceteris paribus. Instrumental variables (IVs) serve as an experimental handle, independent of potential outcomes and potential treatment status and affecting potential outcomes only through potential treatment status. We propose marginal and nested structural models using IVs, in the spir...
متن کاملTargeted maximum likelihood estimation of the parameter of a marginal structural model.
Targeted maximum likelihood estimation is a versatile tool for estimating parameters in semiparametric and nonparametric models. We work through an example applying targeted maximum likelihood methodology to estimate the parameter of a marginal structural model. In the case we consider, we show how this can be easily done by clever use of standard statistical software. We point out differences ...
متن کاملTracking Interval for Doubly Censored Data with Application of Plasma Droplet Spread Samples
Doubly censoring scheme, which includes left as well as right censored observations, is frequently observed in practical studies. In this paper we introduce a new interval say tracking interval for comparing the two rival models when the data are doubly censored. We obtain the asymptotic properties of maximum likelihood estimator under doubly censored data and drive a statistic for testing the ...
متن کاملBounded , efficient and doubly robust estimation with inverse weighting
Consider estimating the mean of an outcome in the presence of missing data or estimating population average treatment effects in causal inference. A doubly robust estimator remains consistent if an outcome regression model or a propensity score model is correctly specified. We build on a previous nonparametric likelihood approach and propose new doubly robust estimators, which have desirable pr...
متن کاملBounded, Efficient, and Doubly Robust Estimation with Inverse Weighting
Consider the problem of estimating the mean of an outcome in the presence of missing data or estimating population average treatment effects in causal inference. A doubly robust estimator remains consistent if an outcome regression model or a propensity score model is correctly specified. We build on the nonparametric likelihood approach of Tan and propose new doubly robust estimators. These es...
متن کامل